Prepared by the ANC with the technical support of WHO and UNICEF
The ANC is in an alliance with the South African Communist Party (SACP) and the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU). Each Alliance partner is an independent organisation with its own constitution, membership and programmes. The Alliance is founded on a common commitment to the objectives of the National Democratic Revolution, and the need to unite the largest possible cross-section of South Africans behind these objectives.
30 May 1994
The South African government, through its apartheid policies, developed a health care system which was sustained through the years by the promulgation of racist legislation and the creation of institutions such as political and statutory bodies for the control of the health care professions and facilities. These institutions and facilities were built and managed with the specific aim of sustaining racial segregation and discrimination in health care.
The net result has been a system which is highly fragmented, biased towards curative care and the private sector, inefficient and inequitable. Team work has not been emphasised, and the doctor has played a dominant role within the hierarchy. There has been little or no emphasis on health and its achievement and maintenance, but there has been great emphasis on medical care.
The challenge facing South Africans is to design a comprehensive programme to redress social and economic injustices, to eradicate poverty, reduce waste, increase efficiency and to promote greater control by communities and individuals over all aspects of their lives. In the health sector this will involve the complete transformation of the national health care delivery system and all relevant institutions. All legislation, organisations and institutions related to health have to be reviewed with a view to attaining the following:
Recognising this need for total transformation of the health sector in South Africa, the African National Congress (ANC) initiated a process of developing an overall National Health Plan based on the Primary Health Care Approach. The first draft of this plan was prepared by a team consisting of members of the ANC Health Department and consultants appointed by the World Health Organization and UNICEF. It was based on documents prepared by the ANC Health Policy Commissions and others in the democratic movement, including a broad process of consultations and amendments.
The second draft was prepared by a similar team, following a national workshop called specifically to discuss and modify the first draft. The second draft was released for public debate and discussions in January 1994. Organisations, institutions and individuals were invited to present written submissions, and the response was enthusiastic and encouraging. The draft was amended accordingly, and the responses received served to strengthen the document considerably.
This document focuses on the health system, but it links with the Reconstruction and Development Programme which involves all other sectors. Health will therefore be viewed from a development perspective, as an integral part of the socio-economic development plan of South Africa.
No planning document can ever be called final: planning for any sector is a dynamic process that must be constantly evaluated and re-evaluated. It is essential that this process is ongoing, to ensure that the vision for health is attained. This process will ensure the development of more detailed programmes in every sphere of health, and we will continue to adopt as inclusive an approach as possible.
Johannesburg, April 1994
The health of all South Africans will be secured mainly through the achievements of equitable social and economic development. The legacy of apartheid policies in South Africa has created large disparities between racial groups in terms of socio-economic status, occupation, education, housing and health. These policies have created a fragmented health system, which has resulted in inequitable access to health care. The inequities in health are reflected in the health status of the most vulnerable groups.
Every person has the right to achieve optimal health, and the ANC is committed to the promotion of health, using the Primary Health Care Approach as the underlying philosophy for restructuring the health system. Primary Health Care (PHC) will form an integral part, both of the country's health system, and of the overall social and economic development of the community. Central to the PHC approach is full community participation in the planning, provision, control and monitoring of services. Democratically elected representatives will play a major role in the structure of the health services.
Health problems have many and complex causes whose solution demands an intersectoral approach. Other sectors such as those providing clean water, sanitation, housing, etc. have a greater impact on health, than health services alone. The health sector has an important advocacy role to play and therefore mechanisms will be developed to ensure that intersectoral activity takes place.
The health sector and health services must increase awareness that a healthy population is necessary for social and economic development. International population trends recognise that development strategies which improve the quality of life of the population, contribute to the decline in fertility. Contraception is a necessary, but not sufficient factor in promoting fertility decline. Population programmes must maximise the capacity for individuals to fully develop their potential for social stability and economic growth. The major aims will be improvements in women's legal, educational and employment status.
The state is responsible for creating the framework within which health is promoted and health care is delivered. It is also a major provider of services. A single comprehensive, equitable and integrated National Health System (NHS) will be created and legislated for. A single governmental structure will coordinate all aspects of both public and private health care delivery and all existing departments will be integrated. The provision of health care will be coordinated among local, district, provincial and national authorities. Authority over, responsibility for, and control over funds will be decentralised to the lowest level possible that is compatible with rational planning, administration, and the maintenance of good quality care. Rural health services will be made accessible with particular attention given to improving transport.
Within the health system, the health services provide the principal and most direct support to the communities. The foundation of the National Health System will be Community Health Centres (CHCs) providing comprehensive services including promotive, preventive, rehabilitative and curative care. Casualty and maternity services will be available as 24-hour services. Community health services will be part of a coordinated District Health System, which will be responsible for the management of all community health services in that district.
Each of the nine provinces will have a Provincial Health Authority responsible for coordinating the health system at this level. At the central level, the National Health Authority (NHA) will be responsible for policy formulation and strategic planning, as well as coordination of the planning and the functioning of the overall health system in the country. It will allocate the national health budget, and will develop guidelines, norms and standards to apply throughout the health system, to translate policy into relevant integrated programmes in health development.
Resources will be rationally and effectively used, and priority will be given to the most vulnerable groups, and to the eradication, prevention and control of major diseases. Mechanisms that will integrate traditional and other complementary health practitioners will be investigated.
The right of all patients to be treated with respect and dignity will be upheld.
To this end, a Charter of Patients Rights will be introduced.
The emphasis on management support will focus on issues of coordination and integration, rational financial management, human resource management, and a comprehensive health information system. Efforts will be aimed at reforming organisational structures, strengthening support systems, improving skills of staff, and developing learning materials and guidelines.
The basis of funding will continue to be from general tax revenue. It is strongly recommended that health services receive a higher proportion of this revenue, which should be increased to at least 4% of GDP (at least 13% of government expenditure). Additional revenue can be derived immediately by increasing the excise on tobacco, which will have an added benefit of reducing consumption. Increased duties on alcohol may also be used to increase revenue, if further studies warrant this.
Free health care will be provided in the public sector for children under six, pregnant and nursing mothers, the elderly, the disabled and certain categories of the chronically ill. Preventive and promotive activities, school health services, antenatal and delivery services, contraceptive services, nutrition support, curative care for public health problems and community based care will also be provided free of charge in the public sector.
User fees for insured patients using public hospitals will be increased to ensure full cost recovery. Facilities will be allowed to retain a proportion of the revenue generated to improve the quality of service delivered.
Priority will be given to primary care facilities and personnel in rural and impoverished urban areas. The reallocation of resources will be coordinated by the NHA. Provinces which are underfunded relative to their needs, will be subsidised.
The state will play a more active role in encouraging efficiency and high quality care in both the public and private sectors. Mechanisms such as licensing and compulsory public service for graduates will be investigated. Capitation, rather than fee-for-service as a method of remuneration will be encouraged.
A Commission of Inquiry to look at the current crisis in the medical aid sector, and to consider alternatives such as a National Health Insurance, will be appointed.
Financial systems and techniques will be developed to ensure efficiency and effectiveness. Strategies that will be used include an effective resource allocation mechanism; the inclusion of financial plans in all plans and programmes; weighting of certain programmes; and performance budgeting systems.
The challenges of the transformation of the health system will require substantial training and reorientation of existing personnel, redistribution of present and future personnel and development of new categories of health personnel. To achieve this the human resources management and planning systems will be improved, the training programmes and selection procedures will be reviewed, and training programmes to re-orient existing personnel will be developed.
To facilitate redistribution of personnel, and effective human resource development, incentives and rewards for working in underserved areas will be offered; communities will be consulted on selection and recruitment; and effective labour relations will be promoted. In order to ensure the appropriate placement and utilisation of health personnel, epidemiological needs assessments will be carried out, and rotation through underserved areas and primary and secondary level facilities will be emphasised.
Health personnel education will be multi-disciplinary, gender sensitive, problem oriented and community-based in character. A number of fast-track training programmes will be introduced for categories of urgently needed personnel.
A Commission of Inquiry will be established to make recommendations on standard conditions of service and employment for all health workers in the public sector.
A comprehensive health information system that is relevant to local, provincial, and national levels will be established. The system will include indicators to monitor apartheid generated disparities in access to health care and health status, as well as a selected list of the indicators developed by the WHO Regional office for Africa.
Priority programmes have been developed, to provide targets for implementing changes to the current health system. All targets should be seen as goals for progressive improvements and depend on the differential needs at provincial and local levels. The principal priorities are maternal and child health, nutrition, the control of communicable diseases, and violence. Special attention will be given to vulnerable groups and this will include the development of programmes for women's health, occupational health, rural areas, mental health, chronic illness, rehabilitation, and the elderly. In addition, the health priorities will also include health promotion, drugs policy, emergency care, substance abuse, environmental health and oral health. A special emphasis in all health programmes and activities at all levels in the system will be given to health promotion.
Through these priorities and the Plan presented here, the ANC demonstrates its political will and commitment to effect change. Ultimately the most effective way to ensure change and transformation of the health system will be the passing of appropriate legislation to give effect to this political will and commitment.
AIDS Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome
ANC African National Congress
CHC Community Health Centre
CHW Community Health Worker
DBSA Development Bank of Southern Africa
DHA District Health Authority
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GNP Gross National Product
HIV Human Immunodeficiency Virus
HRD Human Resource Development
IMR Infant Mortality Rate
MCH Maternal and Child Health
MLL Minimum Living Level
NGO Non-Government Organisation
NHA National Health Authority
NHI National Health Insurance
NHS National Health System
PHC Primary Health Care
PHA Provincial Health Authority
STD Sexually Transmitted Disease
TB Tuberculosis
UNICEF United Nations Children s Fund
WHO World Health Organization
HEALTH VISION
Equity Right to health PHC Approach National Health System Coordination and decentralisation Priorities Promotion of health Respect for all Health information system
THE PRIMARY HEALTH CARE APPROACH
Political will Accountability and community participation Social and economic justice Changing the medical culture The best possible care
INTERSECTORAL COLLABORATION
Other sectors affect health Health influences other sectors President and cabinet Other departments Health, the environment and development
- POPULATION POLICY AND HEALTH
- LINKAGES WITH SOCIAL WELFARE
- THE SOUTHERN AFRICA REGION
Fragmentation Hospital Beds Human Resources Financial Resources
ACCIDENT, EMERGENCY AND RESCUE SERVICES APPROPRIATE HEALTH TECHNOLOGY CARE OF THE ELDERLY CONTROL OF COMMUNICABLE DISEASES DISASTER PREPAREDNESS AND HUMANITARIAN ACTION DRUGS POLICY ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH HEALTH PROMOTION HIV/AIDS and STDs LABORATORY SERVICES MATERNAL AND CHILD HEALTH (MCH) MENTAL HEALTH NON-COMMUNICABLE DISEASES NUTRITION OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH ORAL HEALTH PALLIATIVE CARE REHABILITATION RESEARCH RURAL HEALTH TRADITIONAL PRACTITIONERS VIOLENCE WOMEN'S HEALTH
COMMUNITY LEVEL
Intersectoral Community Development Committee Community Health Committee Community Health Centres Clinics and Health Posts
DISTRICT LEVEL
Intersectoral District Development Committee District Health Authority (DHA) Management Committee District Health Advisory Body Functions of the District Health Authority Health Care Support Services Administration and Finance Planning and Human Resources
PROVINCIAL LEVEL
Intersectoral Provincial Development Committee Provincial Health Authority (PHA) Management Committee Specialist Hospitals Provincial Health Advisory Body Functions of the Provincial Health Authority Health Care Support Services Administration and Finance Planning and Human Resources
NATIONAL LEVEL
Intersectoral National Development Committee National Health Authority National Health Advisory Body Functions of the National Health Authority Health Care Support Services Administration and Finance Planning and Human Resources
THE ROLE OF THE PRIVATE SECTOR AND INDEPENDENT PRACTITIONERS
The Independent Practitioner Cost Containment Private facilities and institutions Traditional and complementary healers
STATUTORY BODIES
THE ROLE OF NGOs INVOLVED IN HEALTH
THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATIONS
MANAGEMENT SUPPORT
HEALTH CARE FINANCING
- Sources of finance
- The allocation of resources for public sector health care
- A National Health Insurance
- Protecting the public sector
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT
Human resource development Staffing the Public Health Sector
HEALTH INFORMATION SYSTEM
6. HEALTH PRIORITIES
HEALTH POLICY PRIORITIES
PRINCIPAL HEALTH PRIORITIES
Maternal and Child Health Nutrition Control of communicable diseases Violence Special programmes for vulnerable groups
OTHER HEALTH PRIORITIES
HEALTH SYSTEM PRIORITIES
FINANCING THE NHS HEALTH FACILITIES HUMAN RESOURCES MANAGING THE NHS EDUCATIONAL AND RESEARCH INSTITUTIONS
LEGISLATION FOR THE NHS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The health of all South Africans will be secured and improved mainly through the achievement of equitable social and economic development such as the level of employment, the standards of education, and the provision of housing, clean water, sanitation and electricity. In addition, reductions in the levels of violence and malnutrition, and promotion of healthy lifestyles should be addressed, as well as the provision of accessible health care services.
Every person has the right to achieve optimal health, and it is the responsibility of the state to provide the conditions to achieve this. Health and health care, like other social services, and particularly where they serve women and children, must not be allowed to suffer as a result of foreign debt or structural adjustment programmes.
The ANC is committed to the promotion of health through prevention and education. The Primary Health Care Approach is the underlying philosophy for the restructuring of the health system. It embodies the concept of community development, and is based on full community participation in the planning, provision, control and monitoring of services. It aims to reduce inequalities in access to health services, especially in the rural areas and deprived communities.
A single comprehensive, equitable and integrated National Health System (NHS) must be created. There will be a single governmental structure dealing with health, based on national guidelines, priorities and standards. It will coordinate all aspects of both public and private health care delivery, and will be accountable to the people of South Africa through democratic structures.
All existing public sector departments of health including local authority, homeland, military and prison services, will be integrated into the NHS. All racial, ethnic, tribal and gender discrimination will be eradicated. Both public and private providers have major contributions to make and will operate within a common framework that will encourage efficiency and high quality care.
The provision of health care will be coordinated among local, district, provincial and national authorities. These will, as far as possible coincide with provincial and local government boundaries. Authority over, responsibility for, and control over funds will be decentralised to the lowest level possible that is compatible with rational planning and the maintenance of good quality care. Clinics, health centres and independent practitioners will be the main points of first contact with the health system. Rural health services will be made accessible with particular attention given to improving transport.
Health services will be planned and regulated to ensure that resources are rationally and effectively used, to make basic health care available to all South Africans, giving priority to the most vulnerable groups. Maternal and child care, the protection of the environment, services in the rural areas, women's health and the care of the disabled will be prioritised. Appropriate services to adolescents and to young adults will also be provided. In addition there will be a focus on the prevention and control of major risk factors and diseases, especially AIDS, tuberculosis, measles, gastro-intestinal disease, trauma, heart disease and common cancers.
Attention will also be given to health education on sexuality, child spacing, oral health, substance abuse, environmental and occupational health.
Health workers at all levels will promote general health and encourage healthy lifestyles. The government will also seek to establish appropriate mechanisms that will lead to the integration of traditional and other complementary healers into the NHS.
Within the health system health workers must respect the right of all people to be treated with dignity and respect. A Charter of Patients Rights will be introduced. Furthermore, individuals, interest groups and communities have the right to participate in the process of formulating and implementing health policy.
Appropriate and reliable data will be systematically collected and analysed, as part of a comprehensive health information system essential for NHS planning and management purposes. It will also allow for promotion of relevant research to address the most important health problems of the community. The public and private sectors will be required to collect and submit relevant data in order to facilitate planning at local, provincial and national levels. The health information system of the NHS will thus gather universal, opportune, reliable, simple and action oriented types of data to inform the entire system and increase its effectiveness.
The new Government must follow the Primary Health Care (PHC) approach to the delivery of health services. Within the PHC approach, PHC itself is central and was defined in the Declaration of Alma Ata as: "Primary Health Care is essential health care based on practical, scientifically sound and socially acceptable methods and technology made universally accessible to individuals and families in the community through their full participation and at a cost that the community and country can afford to maintain at every stage of their development in the spirit of self-reliance and self-determination". PHC will form an integral part of the country's National Health System, of which it will be the central focus, while the PHC approach will guide the overall social and economic development of the community.
The PHC approach requires political will on the part of the government, and commitment from communities, health and allied workers, health policy makers, health service managers and the broad range of health-related sectors (education, sanitation, water supply, electrification, finance, agriculture, small business development etc.). The government will formulate national policies, strategies and plans of action to launch and sustain PHC as part of the comprehensive National Health System and in coordination with other sectors.
An important principle in the primary health care approach is accountability to community structures at local, district, provincial and national levels. Democratically elected representatives will be involved in the appointment of staff and the control of budgets. This is seen as an important mechanism for increasing local control and responsibility over health matters. However, control over the executive functions in the health care system is not the same as community participation. Effective community participation as envisaged in the PHC approach means that democratically elected community structures, integrated with representatives of the different sectors and stake-holders involved in health and community development, have the power to decide on health issues. Community participation is an essential element that the NHS must develop at a local level in order to be fully effective, and is not an entity that can be prescribed and legislated into being.
The introduction of PHC requires a thorough understanding of its various aspects. Indeed, there are philosophical, sociological, economic, political, technical and strategic considerations which cover a wide range of issues, all of vital importance for the operations of the NHS to become effective. The fundamental principle is that of social and economic justice. This understanding is essential for health providers and for the population at large, and also for other sectors in government, NGOs, trade unions and community organisations.
PHC is not just a cheaper, simpler approach to the delivery of health care, nor is it simply basic health interventions. It is a concept which is changing the medical culture. Previously this was centred around health professionals, where the community - the "patients" - were the passive recipients of health services and the doctors and health professionals alone were the dispensers of health. The change will inevitably bring about some radical transformations, not only of the health services and of the training and research institutions, but also of the attitudes of both health providers and those demanding health care services. These transformations will pose a tremendous challenge to the NHS, to the government and to society as a whole.
In essence, PHC offers the only viable alternative for sustainable and equitable health development. The key to health for all South Africans is a national development strategy that incorporates PHC. With its concern for equity in health care, using available appropriate resources, PHC is the best possible form of health care for everyone, rich and poor alike, in any society.
Health problems have many and complex causes whose solution demands an intersectoral approach. The health sector has an important advocacy role in ensuring that policies, programmes and plans in other sectors take account of health. Promoting health requires far more than improving medical services. This is particularly obvious in South Africa, where decades of apartheid have led to grossly inferior education, employment opportunities, housing, income, and environmental conditions. All of these play a significant part in undermining the health status of the majority of the population.
Although it is important to improve access to health services, it should also be recognised that this will have a limited impact on reducing the gross discrepancies in health status which exist. An intersectoral approach is necessary if the extensive role of other interventions in health promotion is to be recognised and promoted. In the past little recognition has been given to the detrimental effects of a variety of social and economic activities on health.
Agricultural policy will influence food availability and price, nutrition, and tobacco smoking. Development activities such as the building of dams, deforestation and the construction of roads may have adverse health consequences. Economic activity aimed at encouraging investment may fail to ensure that safety at work is adequately protected or that child-care facilities are provided to allow women to have equal access to employment. Policies on migrant labour may have an adverse impact on sexually transmitted diseases and HIV/AIDS unless recognition is given to promoting sexual health. Similarly, education policy heavily influences health. Female education is of crucial importance and health related topics can often be used in the teaching of many subjects. Alcohol policy has an impact on the incidence of trauma, and on mental health, especially in relation to violence within communities and families. Building and town planning regulations, and the degree to which they are enforced, profoundly affect the degree to which people with disabilities are able to function normally in society.
Health also influences other sectors. Good health is required if the skills creativity and productive abilities of our people are to be maximised. A healthy and secure community is much more likely to be able to play a positive role in development. A population which is poorly nourished, unwell, in pain, requiring treatment, or psychologically stressed is unlikely to be able to make a positive contribution to the wellbeing of the community at large. The health sector, and health services, must increase awareness that a healthy population is necessary for meeting basic needs as well as for appropriate development on a large scale.
Over the past decades, in many other countries, policies promoting primary health care, safer communities, healthy cities, and 'health for all' have embraced an intersectoral approach. South Africa has relatively little experience of working within such a framework, due to the historical division between government and the people. Developing appropriate methods of cooperation will require a process of establishing trust and working together with representative structures at all levels.
Different methods will need to be employed at different levels of government to ensure intersectoral collaboration, accountability and participation.
The President and the Cabinet must take the major responsibility for ensuring that the different sectors work together to achieve the goals of the Reconstruction and Development Programme, including the promotion of health. The Secretary for Health must ensure that mechanisms for improving communication, integration and collaboration between different health sector activities are promoted and evaluated. She or he must also ensure that other departments understand and take into account the likely positive and negative consequences for health of actions or policies in their own sectors.
The Education authorities in particular must ensure that there is a rapid increase in literacy and must implement specific programmes in schools on sexuality, on healthy nutrition, on diseases of lifestyle and on general health promotion. Those responsible for drafting legislation must take responsibility for ensuring that intersectoral consultation has taken place before any legislation is presented to parliament. The economic departments must take responsibility for the evaluation of health impacts, including environmental impacts, of trade, industry and other economic policies. The police and prison authorities must recognise their potentials for promoting health as well as the negative impacts of their work on health.
Training of health workers must give recognition to the role of other sectors in the promotion of health. Training of development workers and development study programmes should emphasise the potential positive and negative effects of development on health, and of health on development.
Such an approach can be used to ensure proper housing, water and sanitation facilities, to maintain a clean environment, to encourage the development of community facilities such as creches, pre-schools, youth centres and recreation centres, facilities for senior citizens, and to help control criminal activity. All this will lead to very much better mental, physical and social health for the whole population and will facilitate a shift in emphasis from disease and illness to health.
Special attention will be given by the government to the interaction between health, the environment and overall development, in line with the recommendations of the Earth Summit (Rio, 1992), and more specifically with Agenda 21. The goal of environmental strategies for health, as set out in Principle 1 of the Rio Declaration on Environment and Development, is the recognition that human beings are at the centre of concerns for sustainable development. They are entitled to a healthy and productive life in harmony with nature.
Attaining this goal of healthy people in a healthy environment requires far more than the application of medical technology or even the total efforts of the health sector working alone. The government will integrate efforts by all sectors, organisations and individuals to make socioeconomic development sustainable and humane, ensuring a sound environmental basis for health. Within such cooperative efforts, health workers have leadership, advisory, and support functions to perform. These functions will be adequately addressed within the NHS to allow for the effective promotion of this multi-disciplinary concept.
The South African population is growing rapidly in spite of the decline in urban fertility rates in recent years. The annual growth rate is 2.5% (1990) with the African population showing the highest growth rate. This must be seen in the context of gross maldistribution and underutilisation of the country's resources.
International population trends recognise that development strategies which improve the quality of life of the population contribute significantly to the decline in fertility. The development of population programmes to maximise the capacity for individuals to fully develop their potential for social stability and economic growth is required. Improvement in women's legal, educational and employment status will help to reduce the rates of infant mortality, maternal mortality and morbidity, and teenage pregnancy.
Contraception is a necessary but not sufficient factor in promoting fertility decline. Moreover, contraception should not be provided independently of broader reproductive health care within a comprehensive primary health care system. The population policy should promote reproductive freedom of choice and women's right to control their bodies. It should also recognise the human rights of individuals and couples freely and responsibly to decide the number and spacing of their children, and to have the information, education and means to do so.
The increasing numbers of the South African population, the shifting geographical distribution and the patterns of internal and international migration, all call for clear economic and social policies to help achieve a balanced development process which will redress some of the inequalities caused by apartheid.
Social welfare, of all the sectors related to health, forms the closest links. Health is defined as "a state of complete physical, mental and social wellbeing, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity". Social welfare therefore has a major role to play in improving health status.
An important area of activity for social welfare is the organisation and administration of a social security net. There are also a number of areas of overlap between social welfare and health, such as violence, alcoholism care of the elderly, and services for people with disabilities. Historically, however, health and social welfare departments have tended to work independently. Urgent attention needs to be given to the development of mechanisms to ensure that there are active linkages between health and welfare. One alternative is to combine health and welfare as one department. The danger of this approach is that welfare could be subsumed or dominated by the medical aspects of health. Another alternative is to have separate departments but to have active cooperation between health and welfare especially in areas of common programmes. These and other alternatives need to be discussed with relevant social welfare organisations and departments.
As has been pointed out in the Reconstruction and Development Programme published by the ANC, sustainable reconstruction and development in South Africa requires sustainable reconstruction and development in Southern Africa as a whole. Otherwise, the region will face continued high unemployment and underemployment, leading to labour migration and brain drain to the more industrialised areas. The democratic government must negotiate with neighbouring countries to forge an equitable and mutually beneficial programme of increasing cooperation, coordination and integration appropriate to the conditions of the region. In the health sector, South Africa has a great deal to learn from other countries in the region, particularly about the implementation of primary health care policies and programmes. South Africa can also contribute significantly to health and health care in the region. Sound economic and development policies, technical cooperation and support, and greater access to high technology training facilities and to tertiary care in South Africa, can all benefit the whole region.
The legacy of apartheid policies in South Africa has created large disparities between racial groups in terms of socio-economic status, occupation, education, housing and health. These policies have created a fragmented health system, which has resulted in inequitable access to health care. The inequities in health are reflected in the health status of the most vulnerable groups.
Good quality data on population needs, on local communities, and particular sub-groups are essential for rational planning and evaluation of services. Unfortunately, available data are often inadequate, unreliable, or incomplete. The data used here are taken from the best available, and a very wide variety, of sources.
The South African government has created in its legislation artificial classifications of people into African, Coloured, Indian, and White. It is necessary to use this classification as it highlights the disparities in health status and conditions, as data have been collected according to this, and not according to social class as is customary in other countries. Use of this terminology does not imply its acceptance or legitimacy. In order to separate out the disparities between Whites and the other groups, the term "Black" is used to mean African, Coloured, and Indian groups combined.
South Africa's population for 1991 was 37.7 million but is projected to be 47 million by the year 2000. The growth rate of the African population is 2.7% per annum, compared with 0.7% in the White population. The annual average population growth rate for 1980-1991 was 2.5 percent and is projected to be 2.2 percent for 1991-2000.
Africans comprise 75% of the total population, Whites 13%, Coloureds 9%, and Indians 3%. The White population group is 90% urbanised, compared to only 50% among Africans, although there is rapid urbanisation in the latter group.
In 1991, 36% of the population were children between the ages of 0 and 14 years, while approximately 46% of the population were under the age of 19 years. It is estimated that children under the age of 4 years form 13% of the total population. The proportion of females in the South African population is 52.7%, with a higher proportion in the rural areas.
Historic population growth rates and 1988 projections in percent per annum
| Year | African | Coloured | Indian | White | Total |
| 1980 | 2.98 | 2.06 | 2.00 | 1.41 | 2.54 |
| 1985 | 3.00 | 1.94 | 1.89 | 1.41 | 2.66 |
| 1990* | 2.96 | 1.87 | 1.72 | 0.58-0.76 | 2.50 |
| 1995* | 2.88 | 1.68 | 1.48 | 0.58-0.76 | 2.44 |
| 2000* | 2.79 | 1.41 | 1.28 | 0.58-0.76 | 2.36 |
| 2005* | 2.70 | 1.16 | 0.97 | 0.58-0.76 | 2.28 |
* Population projections
Percentage distribution of population in 1990
| Urban | Rural | Total | |
| African | 49.5 | 50.5 | 100 |
| Coloured | 83.8 | 16.2 | 100 |
| Indian | 95.7 | 4.3 | 100 |
| White | 92.4 | 7.6 | 100 |
| RSA | 59.0 | 41.0 | 100 |
The average annual growth rate of the GDP in the period 1970-1980 was 3%, compared with a declining figure of 1.3% for 1980-1991. The average annual rate of inflation was 13.0 and 14.4 percent in these periods respectively.
Africans comprise 95% of the 18 million people in South Africa currently existing below the accepted "minimum living level" (MLL) of R 750 per month per household, with 60% of this group living in total poverty. Although the African population is in the majority, it is estimated that they receive only 27% of the total income. It is estimated that between 8 and 9 million of this population group are destitute, relying on social grants and support schemes. Approximately 64% of the economically active population are Blacks, but they occupy only 15% of the professional, semiprofessional, technical, managerial and executive positions. Black people perform largely unskilled work, and unemployment rates are high. Illiteracy is a major problem and it is estimated that three million adults in South Africa are functionally illiterate.
Percentage population below minimum living level in 1989
| Urban | Rural | Total |
|
| African | 31.9 | 68.3 | 52.7 |
| Coloured | 23.2 | 45.0 | 28.1 |
| Indian | 8.3 | 45.0 | 10.7 |
| White | 1.5 | 2.0 | 1.6 |
| RSA excl TBVC | 21.1 | 63.3 | 40.1 |
| TBVC homelands | 65.1 | ||
| Overall | 44.8 |
The urban housing backlog in 1990 was conservatively estimated at 1,3 million units. If hostels and rural areas are included, the backlog rises to approximately 3 million units, of which approximately 90% are needed by African households. It was estimated that up to 7 million people lived in informal settlements in the urban areas in 1991. Gross overcrowding and unacceptable sanitary conditions are prevalent amongst the majority of Blacks in the urban and peri-urban areas.
The Development Bank of South Africa (DBSA) estimates that of the 22 million urban population, 62% have waterborne sewage systems, 33% have minimal sewage facilities and 5% have bucket systems, ventilated improved latrines (VIP) or aquatrines. However, local surveys suggest that in many communities, particularly in informal settlements, large numbers of people have no access at all to sanitation facilities. Of the 16 million rural population, rough estimates indicate that 53% have a safe and accessible water supply and 14% have access to adequate sanitation defined as either a VIP or a flush latrine. Sixty five percent of the South African population has no electricity.
Percentage Africans supplied with electricity by area
| Metro formal | 83 |
| Urban | 36 |
| Metro informal | 20 |
| Rural | 11 |
Infectious and parasitic diseases cause 14% of deaths amongst Black people, but only 2% of deaths among Whites. Cardiovascular diseases, on the other hand cause 12% of deaths among Blacks (4 million), but 40% of deaths among Whites (2 million). Mortality and morbidity are strongly related to poor environmental and socio-economic circumstances as well as to lifestyle. Chronic disease is emerging as an increasing problem in all population groups.
There is no compulsory registration of births and deaths for Africans and the data on Infant Mortality Rates (IMR) are variable and unreliable. In 1991 the infant mortality rate was 54 per 1,000 live births. For Black children the IMR was between 94 and 124. The major causes of death are infectious diseases, especially intestinal infection, and respiratory diseases. These figures have been computed from registered deaths, but the estimated deaths are higher, especially in the rural areas.
The maternal mortality rate in 1989 was 8 per 100,000 for Whites and more than 58 per 100,000 for Africans. In 1991 life expectancy was 63 years. The life expectancy at birth for Whites is 9 years more than that for Blacks, as an increase in life expectancy is influenced by a decrease in IMR.
Infant Mortality Rate in rural areas of the homelands of South Africa
| Period | Area | IMR/1,000 |
| 1973-80 | Transkei | 130.0 |
| 1982 | Gelukspan, Bophuthatswana | 38.5 |
| 1973-82 | Naphuno, Lebowa | 51.0 |
| 1982-83 | Donald Fraser, Venda | 36.0 |
| 1981-86 | Hewu, Ciskei | 41.0 |
| 1976-88 | Elim, Gazankulu | 88.0 |
Maternal mortality rate per 100,000 in South Africa in 1989
| Africans | 58 |
| Coloureds | 22 |
| Indians | 8 |
| Whites | 5 |
In 1989, 2.3 million people were considered to be in need of nutritional assistance. Of these, 92% were children below the age of twelve years, and 8% were pregnant and lactating women.
Tuberculosis is by far the most frequently occurring notifiable disease. The annual case load increased by 4% between 1987 and 1988. In 1988 the prevalence rate was 489 per 100,000 population, with the Western Cape having the highest rates in the country. The incidence in 1990 was 229 per 100,000.
Tuberculosis case load in 1988, in thousands of cases
| Africans | 66 |
| Coloureds | 30 |
| Indians | 1 |
| Whites | 1 |
In 1989, the measles notification rate per 100,000 population was 43.1 for Africans and 3.8 for Whites. Vaccination coverage varies between the different population groups and geographical areas.
Violence has become one of the most important causes of morbidity, disability and mortality. The non-natural causes of fatalities in South Africa are three times higher than the WHO estimate for the world. It is estimated that violence caused more than 2,000 deaths per month in 1993, and caused many other people to become disabled. Less than 15% of these deaths were politically related. Mortality, morbidity and disability from motor vehicle accidents is also increasing, much of it related to alcohol abuse, with many victims being pedestrians.
Studies estimate that 5 million people in South Africa suffer from mental illness and 150,000 attempt suicide each year.
HIV/AIDS is emerging as a major public health problem, with over 2,000 reported cases at the end of 1993, and 500,000 people infected with HIV. Forecasts to the year 2000 predict that there will be between 4 and 7 million HIV-positive cases, with about 60% of total deaths due to AIDS, if HIV prevention and control measures remain unaddressed. Similarly, credible predictions indicate that by the year 2005, between 18% and 24% of the adult population will be infected with HIV, that the cumulative death toll will be 2.3 million, and that there will be about 1.5 million AIDS orphans.
The public sector health-care system in South Africa is highly fragmented. At the central level there were nominally four departments of health, one for each racial group. In 1993, with rationalisation, these departments were combined into one. In addition, each of the ten homelands has its own department of health. At present there are eleven departments of health.
The provincial administrations of the four provinces are the second tier of government, responsible for hospital services, ambulances and outpatient services. There are almost 800 local authorities which form the third tier of the health-care system. They are responsible largely for environmental services, public health and promotive and preventive health care services.
There is also a strong but fragmented private sector which includes health professionals in private practice, private hospitals, pharmaceutical manufacturers and distributors, medical aid schemes, and others.
In 1988 there were 693 hospitals in South Africa, and 158,567 hospital beds (public and private), of which 28% were in the private sector. About a quarter of private sector beds are in "fee-for-service" hospitals. There has been a rapid growth in fee-for-service hospitals in recent years, with a 61% increase in the number of these beds between 1983 and 1990. Ninety-four percent of fee-for-service hospital beds are in the urban areas.
The 1988 data showed that there were, overall, 4.4 beds per 1,000 population in South Africa. However, homelands have only 2.7 beds per 1,000 population, and the non-metropolitan areas have 4.0 beds per 1,000 population, compared with 7.1 per 1,000 in the metropolitan areas. There are 1.9 tertiary beds per 1,000 population, compared with 1.5 general acute beds per 1,000 population. There is, therefore, a relative undersupply of acute general beds.
Hospital bed occupancy rates average 75%, but public hospitals in homelands and black urban hospitals often show occupancy rates above 100%.
There are similar disparities in the distribution of laboratory services and pharmacies.
There are 2,218 health care clinics in the public sector in South Africa, and an average of 16,190 people per clinic. If the recommended WHO ratio of 10,000 people per clinic is used as a guideline, the shortfall in the number of clinics needed in 1988 was 1,373. Using population figures to the year 2000, the shortfall to that year will be 2,541.
In 1990 there were 22,260 medical doctors registered in South Africa out of whom 6,087 had a registered medical speciality. The ratio of doctors to population in the metropolitan areas is approximately 1:700, compared to 1:1,900 in non-metropolitan areas. In the homelands it is estimated that there are between 10,000 to 30,000 people per doctor. In 1980,48% of doctors worked in the private sector. By 1989, this proportion had increased to 58%. Seventy-seven per-cent of doctors reside in metropolitan areas and female doctors comprise about one third of total doctors; however there are few African female doctors.
In 1988 there were 3,581 dentists registered, with over 93% working in the private sector; there were 1,130 clinical psychologists with 92% in the private sector; and 8,311 pharmacists with the majority in the private sector.
Out of 109,236 qualified nursing professionals in 1990, 48% were African, 35% White, 2% Asian and 15% Coloured. In 1990, about 21% of these nurses were employed in private hospitals, compared with 17% in 1987.
It has been estimated that there are approximately 350,000 traditional healers in South Africa. mainly in the rural areas.
These figures reflect a number of prominent problems in human resources development that need to be addressed, some of which are:
The health care services at present are geared to the needs of a minority of the population. Health care in South Africa is sharply divided between the private sector, for those who can afford to pay and/or who belong to medical aid schemes, and the public sector for the indigent.
Approximately R21.6 billion is currently spent on health services in South Africa (between 6 - 6.5% of GNP). Within the public sector, there is a maldistribution of financial resources, with provinces having higher per capita expenditure than the homelands, and higher expenditure for tertiary care than primary care. Financial resources are evenly divided between the public and private sectors, with 50% of the total overall health care expenditure attributable to the 20% of the population who are members of a medical scheme. This excludes private expenditures on traditional healers, and out-of-pocket payments.
As at the 1990/91 financial year, the State Government allocated 11.7% of the budget to health care which was not a significant change from the 11.2% allocated in 1985. Public sector health expenditure has been declining in real per capita terms over the past few years. For example, estimated real per capita expenditure by the provincial administrations had decreased to R182 in 1992/93 from a peak of R276 in 1988/89. The provincial administrations, which are largely responsible for hospital-based care, account for more than two-thirds of total public sector health expenditure. Of this, 43% is directed to academic hospitals; approximately 30% of total public sector expenditure is devoted to these hospitals. In contrast, the local authorities, which are largely responsible for promotive and preventive services, account for approximately 4% of total public sector health expenditure.
Within the ten homelands, where 44% of the total South African population lives, only 19% of the National Health Budget was allocated in 1990/91. In 1993 the ANC initiated, in conjunction with the World Bank, a Health Expenditure Review, because of the poor quality or complete lack of data on health expenditure in South Africa, especially in the homelands and in the private sector. The work of this group will be completed during 1994.
This chapter details the main principles of the ANC policies for a variety of areas, and the mechanisms through which it is felt those policies may best be implemented. Each area is the subject of separate, more extensive documentation, which gives greater operational details. The areas are listed below in alphabetical order. Priorities for implementation of the these various policies appear in Chapter 6. Whereas the policies are listed here in the manner given, this is not to be construed that they are viewed as vertical programmes: rather, programmes will be developed such that they are implemented at all levels in an integrated manner as part of the comprehensive services rendered by the total health team.
It should also be emphasised that promotion and protection of health constitutes a major component of each and every health activity, as envisaged in this plan, which is committed to healthy living and healthy life style rather than curative care as the main thrust. To redress the imbalance of the inherited health status from the apartheid period, curative, palliative and rehabilitative measures will be supported by promotion and prevention measures in the health services.
Many accidents and emergency situations can be prevented, and a major element of health policy will be the promotion of accident prevention. This will include interaction with almost every other sector and with the broad public to build a society in which accidents are less frequent and less serious. This section of the National Health Plan deals with services that will be available throughout the country at all times. Planning and preparedness to render humanitarian assistance in disaster situations is a separate subject and is dealt with later in this chapter.
Accident, emergency and rescue services are very visible and their existence creates a sense of security. Conversely the lack of access to such services in most communities in South Africa causes many people great anxiety and leads to deaths and disabilities that are preventable. Such services can and must be provided in South Africa within a primary health care budget.
The principal tenets of the policy on emergency services include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
An important factor for the success of Primary Health Care is the appropriate use of health technology, by which is meant the association of methods, techniques and equipment which, together with the people using them, can contribute significantly to solving health problems. This includes the use and adaptation of highly sophisticated technology.
However, it is necessary to be aware that there is often pressure from the affluent elite to acquire expensive diagnostic and/or therapeutic technology whilst ignoring the role that a destructive lifestyle may have played in creating the need for that technology.
The principal tenets of the policy on appropriate health technology include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
The elderly, like other vulnerable groups, have been neglected by an uncaring apartheid society. Elderly Africans, particularly those living in rural areas, have suffered even more than the rest of the elderly. Furthermore, as South Africa undergoes the demographic transition experienced by most developing countries, the numbers of elderly people are likely to increase significantly. The NHS will have to provide quality health care to many more elderly people.
The principal tenets of the policy on elderly people include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
Communicable diseases, both among adult and childhood populations, are one of the main causes of morbidity and mortality in South Africa. Tuberculosis alone is the most frequently occurring notifiable disease and a complex public health problem which continues to deteriorate. Measles and gastrointestinal diseases among children still carry high prevalence and case fatality rates. Hepatitis B, acute respiratory infections, STDs and malaria are also cause for great concern because of their high prevalence.
The principal tenets of the policy on communicable diseases include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
Different types of emergency situations occur when various kinds of disaster strike. Such disasters include drought, floods, earthquakes, cyclones, socio-political conflicts, epidemics, industrial accidents, etc., which comprise a combination of human and natural causes.
Every disaster has its own special features. Some can be foreseen hours and even days beforehand, but most occur without warning. Whatever the type of disaster, for some hours the communities and local health personnel have only themselves to rely on before outside assistance arrives.
The principal tenets of the policy on disaster preparedness and humanitarian action include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
A written drug policy entrenched in legislation to ensure its regulation is urgently required. It is necessary to ensure that all people in the country are rationally treated with the necessary drugs and vaccines, to enable their protection and cure from common diseases. The National Drug Policy (NDP) will incorporate strategies for the effective application of drugs within the framework of the NHS. The promotive, preventive and rehabilitative aspects of health care will receive proper emphasis and will not be made subservient to the curative aspect, with its reliance on the use of drugs. A broad approach to cost containment will be taken to ensure overall cost-effectiveness.
The principal tenets of the drug policy include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
Environmental Health services will identify all potential threats to human health in the environment in order to define effective control mechanisms.
The principal tenets of the policy on environmental health include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
Promoting good health and preventing disease is central to the success of Primary Health Care. However, health promotion is not well understood in South Africa and many people equate health promotion with health education.
Health promotion combines diverse approaches such as legislation, fiscal measures such as taxation, controls on advertising, community action and development, intersectoral programmes, environmental monitoring and education.
The principal tenets of the policy on health promotion include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
In view of the devastating implications of the HIV/AIDS epidemic for South Africa, it is mandatory to define prevention and control interventions plus comprehensive care for those already infected, within the context of the Bill of Rights.
The principal tenets of the policy on HIV/AIDS include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
South African Health Laboratory services are plagued by gross fragmentation and duplication with serious disparities in laboratory service provision, especially along racial and geographic lines. There is a need, therefore, for restructuring and/or reorienting all existing laboratory services, including private and forensic ones, and the establishment of a National Health Laboratory Service.
The principal tenets of the policy on laboratory services include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
An investment in the health of children is an investment in the future of the nation. The strength of a health system is reflected in the health status of children. As young children are especially vulnerable and dependent on their mothers, they need special protection and support at all times, especially in times of conflicts, natural disasters and economic hardship. MCH policy will be located within a general development policy providing access to an adequate standard of living. The emphasis will be on health promotion and disease prevention, which will have a far greater impact on child survival than just treatment of disease. It is vital that any programme that is developed in MCH is not vertical, and adopts an integrated, comprehensive approach.
The high maternal mortality rates are of great concern, especially amongst the disadvantaged. A key focus of the MCH policy is improving the health status of women and ensuring that mechanisms are created so that no mother dies because of lack of access to health services.
The principal tenets of the policy on MCH include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
The aim of the mental health policy will be to ensure the psychological wellbeing of all South Africans and to enhance their ability to conduct themselves effectively in social, interpersonal and work relationships. As psychological well-being is determined by social and material conditions as well as by physical, spiritual and emotional health, the policy will aim to eliminate fragmentation of services and ensure comprehensive and integrated mental health care.
The principal tenets of the policy on mental health include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
An increasingly large number of South Africans suffer and die from noncommunicable diseases (NCDs), and this has an important negative effect on the South African economy. These include diseases related to personal behaviours - such as alcohol abuse, smoking and unhealthy eating habits as well as those associated with contamination of the environment and food chain by chemical and radioactive substances. Both unhealthy personal behaviours and environmental pollution are ultimately rooted in the way the economy and society are organised, and it will require fundamental structural changes for a reduction in their prevalence to be achieved.
The problem with many of these diseases is the long period between exposure to risk and onset of disease so that controlling the epidemic demands a multifaceted approach. This will involve the promotion of healthy lifestyles, community action for the implementation of healthy public policies, legislation, measures to reduce the consumption and abuse of tobacco and alcohol, environmental protection and improved recreational facilities.
The principal tenets of the policy on non-communicable diseases include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following
Good nutrition is basic to development and is of fundamental importance to improve health status, especially that of vulnerable groups. It is the PHC component which is most inter-related with other sectors, and where health has a vital advocacy role to play. In addition, integrated PHC services in South Africa will include a nutrition component to identify and address nutrition-related disorders.
The principal tenets of the policy on nutrition include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
Workers' health protection and promotion will be integrated into the national strategies for health development. Accordingly, occupational health programmes and services will emphasise a comprehensive, multidisciplinary and participatory approach, stressing both prevention and rehabilitation, and identifying high-risk and underserved occupational groups.
The principal tenets of the policy on workers' health include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
There is a need to develop new models of oral health care appropriate to South African conditions, by giving priority to comprehensive preventive, promotive and curative primary health care. Profound changes are needed not only in the type and manner of providing oral health care, but also in the way oral health workers are trained, employed, supervised and supported.
The principal tenets of the policy on oral health include the following tenets:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
Relief of chronic pain and care of people with terminal illness are important components of health care that have been seriously neglected in South Africa. Although some cancers are curable, most are not, and 80% of people with advanced cancer suffer from pain, with or without other major symptoms. Cancers are becoming more common and are now the fourth commonest cause of death. AIDS is another incurable disease which is increasing significantly. If South Africa is to become a more caring society, people with these diseases must receive high quality care, including active and effective management of pain and other symptoms.
The principle tenet of the policy on palliative care is:
This tenet will be translated into action through the following:
Rehabilitation is a component of health care that has a special implication for people with disabilities. Rehabilitation services will aim to improve the quality of life of all people, according to international standards, to allow for their total integration into society in a dignified and productive manner, as near as possible to their communities. In addition, special attention will be given to addressing the health needs of people with disabilities under all other health policy areas.
The principal tenets of the policy on rehabilitation include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
It is important to uphold the principles of promoting research that aims at improving the health of people in South Africa and ensuring that resources available for the health sector achieve maximum results. Therefore it is important that a balance is reached between applied, basic and clinical research. The policy is to initiate and sustain effective consultations amongst various health care providers and the public at large to overcome the isolation and fragmentation of research efforts, and to establish and strengthen close links between research, policy and action.
The principal tenets of the policy on research include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
All the principles of the primary health care approach become most evident in the need to provide adequate and equitable services in the rural areas. Provision of health care, appropriate health facilities, and human and financial resources are of prime importance, especially as many of the rural areas have been so neglected, and this imbalance should be redressed.
The principle tenets of the policy for the rural areas include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
Traditional healing will become an integral and recognised part of health care in South Africa. Consumers will be allowed to chose whom to consult for their health care, and legislation will be changed to facilitate controlled use of traditional practitioners.
The principal tenets of the policy on traditional practitioners include the following:
Many factors, but most noticeably the inequities generated by apartheid are the root of the extremely violent society that South Africa has become recently. Promoting peace and security for all people is not only a pre-requisite for health development but for the overall process of reconstruction and socio-economic development. The strong support from the broad mass of the people for the National Peace Initiative must be expanded so as to draw in all South African society to combat all forms of violence including domestic violence, child abuse, rape and robbery. Political violence, contrary to common belief, contributes less than 15% to the more than 2000 violent deaths that occur every month.
The principal tenets of the health policy on violence include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following:
Women's health shall be understood within a socio-economic context and not within the narrow context of women's reproductive health. Priority will be given to the improvement of women's social and economic status. In addition to legislation which guarantees equality, the development of national infrastructure, specifically on water and fuel, will be made an immediate priority. The aim will be to empower women through improved knowledge about their bodies and their health. Another aim is to reduce the number of abortions, and the physical and psychological morbidity, and mortality associated with "back-street" abortions.
The principal tenets of the policy on women's health include the following:
These policy principles will be translated into action through the following mechanisms:
The state has two separate functions with regard to health. The first is to create, monitor and amend the framework (the National Health System) within which health is promoted and health care is delivered. The second function is to be a major provider of services.
The framework is essential for planning, for protecting the public as consumers of health care from exploitation and abuse, and for mediating between conflicting interests. It will be created through legislation and regulation and will be influenced through many other mechanisms, including fiscal and financial policies. The framework includes the powers, functions, rules and regulations of all the various health authorities and of statutory bodies such as the Medicines Control Council and the Councils that register health professionals.
The government's function as a health care provider is to ensure that everyone has access to good quality health care. At present public and private providers are often seen as being in opposition to each other, but if the framework is well constructed then the two sets of providers will complement each other.
The aim of reorganising health services in South Africa is to improve health and health services for all. This will be done by adopting the PHC approach and bringing the services into line with international thinking and practises. Crucial to this will be the strengthening of community services and the development of District Health Systems.
The primary health care approach is centred on the individual, the family and the community. The support they receive for treating and preventing disease, and for protecting, maintaining and improving their health is integrated across health and health related sectors. These include housing, water, sanitation, agriculture, education, social welfare, environment, trade and commerce etc. Within the health system, the health services provide the principal and most direct support to the community.
One of the aims of this Plan is to decentralise management of the delivery of services to provinces, districts and institutions in order to increase efficiency, local innovation, empowerment and accountability. However, in order for decentralisation to be effective, there is an absolute need for central coordination within an integrated, unique and comprehensive NHS. Health services in South Africa have been so fragmented and inequitably distributed that it is essential to unify them into a single system. Decentralisation without coordination and planning could result in a more fragmented, inequitable system.
In this Plan, recognition is given to the central role that the National Health Authority has to play in coordination, evaluation and planning, allocation of budgets, and health personnel issues including conditions of service and employment for health workers. It is envisaged that as the system develops, as management skills increase, as a culture of coordinated action emerges and as there is greater equity of access to health care, greater decentralisation will be both possible and desirable.
The integration of the Defence Force health services (South African Medical Services) with the rest of the public health services will require further discussion. However, as much integration as possible will be encouraged, particularly with regard to supplies and distribution, the adoption of national norms and standards, and the use of military facilities for the communities where they are situated.
Organograms reflecting the structure and function of the health services at all levels usually give disproportionate emphasis to support services in relation to the functions and responsibilities of health care. For this reason health care - promotion, prevention, curative care and rehabilitation - should be viewed as the central task of the health services in support of the health needs of the communities. Health care, as a function at all levels of the health care system receives support from a variety of services (see Fig 15).
An underlying principle is the promotion of the concept of a continuum of health care. There needs to be a change in the culture of health care provision if this is to become meaningful. People who are referred from one part of the health system to another, or from one person to another, must feel that their referral is logical and that they are still within one coordinated system. The structure has been designed to promote teamwork and "Health Care" will include both primary and hospital care to ensure the continuum of health care from the primary to the tertiary levels.
Until such time as Act 200 of 1993 is implemented, the existing provincial administrations, self-governing states and former TBVC countries will pool their financial and other resources for health care. Joint administrations can be established to ensure the smooth running of the health services during the transitional period. This provides the first steps in the rational reconstitution of health services in the country.
The term "community" is used here to represent those people living in the geographical area served by a Community Health Centre. It is not a level of governance but is the most important level for the delivery of comprehensive primary health care.
All communities will be encouraged to form intersectoral Community Development Committees, whose members will be elected from the community. This committee will have advocacy and advisory roles, to help coordinate all aspects of development, and ensure that resources are used to the best advantage of all in the community. It will be particularly important in rural and other disadvantaged communities.
The function of the Community Health Committee will be to liaise with those employed to run their health facility, to examine the budget and to help determine local policies. They will identify and prioritise community health needs and will present these to the District Health Authority (see later). The committee will comprise voluntary elected community representatives (who will be in the majority), representatives from the health services in the area, NGOs working in the community, local health practitioners, and others.
The foundation of the NHS will be Community Health Centres (CHCs) which provide comprehensive services including promotive, preventive, curative and rehabilitative care. Each CHC will be responsible for health in its catchment area and, depending on needs and resources, will also run, as an integral part of its activities, fixed satellite clinics. Staff will also be sent to visit health posts in the area. As a guideline, a CHC will serve, on average, a population of about 50,000 but this may vary widely depending on population density, transport, access and other services in the district. There will be at least one CHC in each health district. In many areas, one of the existing clinics will be upgraded to the level of a CHC. Determination of numbers and siting of CHCs and clinics will be based on a population needs approach.
CHCs are community resources, and ideally should be situated within or close to community development and recreation centres. Parts of existing facilities can be used, for example, for educational support services and other community activities.
The CHC team will include a full range of health workers in order to deliver a comprehensive service. An important part of its activities will be promotive and preventive services. Ambulatory care, with some beds for overnight care, will also be provided. Casualty and maternity services will be available 24 hours a day. Other services will include mother and child care, immunisation, family planning, STD counselling and treatment. treatment for minor trauma and locally prevalent diseases, oral health care, the follow-up treatment and rehabilitation of people with chronic disorders or disabilities, counselling and mental health services, and primary welfare care. The CHC will have an appropriate stock of essential drugs including vaccines, and support services such as radiology and laboratory services for diagnostic and investigative procedures. lndependent health practitioners will have ready access to the CHC for follow-through of their patients, and will also be encouraged to undertake sessions at the CHC.
Nutrition rehabilitation and support programmes will also be integrated into the structure and function of CHCs and health teams, as will environmental health services in the district. Depending on local need, outreach education and health promotion and prevention programmes will be run in schools and work-places.
Clinics will offer a comprehensive range of preventive, promotive, curative and rehabilitation services but at a less specialised level than CHCs. Clinics will normally only be open on weekdays but this can be negotiated with the local communities. Where transport and communication are difficult, particularly in rural areas, arrangements will be made for a member of staff to sleep at the clinic and to be available to give first aid and to summon help in an emergency. All clinics must have water, electricity and communication systems.
Health Posts are places that are not used as full time health facilities but are visited regularly by teams of health workers from the nearby clinic or CHC. They are very important for bringing services closer to the people who need them most.
People with disabilities have particular difficulty in gaining access to health services and special consideration will be given to bringing services closer to them.
* DISTRICT LEVEL
The development of health districts will be crucial to the transformation of the health system and the decentralised management of the new NHS. Provinces will be subdivided into districts mainly on the basis of functional and geographic coherence. The district boundaries will, as far as possible, be coterminous with those of the administrative and political boundaries in order to facilitate effective, integrated and comprehensive service delivery. Population size will be one of the criteria for subdivision. The population of most districts could vary from 50,000 to 750,000 people given the varying densities in urban and rural areas.
The District Health Authorities (DHAs) will be accountable to the elected political authorities. In the case of districts which coincide with the boundaries of a single Local Authority (LA), the DHA will be an integral part of the LA. Where a district includes more than one LA, the DHA will include representatives from each of the LAs in proportion to their population.
All community level health services in the public sector will fall under the DHAs from which they will receive essential material and logistic support. Community level services in the private sector will also be accountable to, and coordinated by, the DHA.
INTERSECTORAL DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE
Intersectoral coordination will be ensured through the establishment of an Intersectoral Development Committee on which the DHA will be represented. This committee will ensure that health concerns are addressed by sectors such as Education, Engineering, Water Affairs, Agriculture and any other sectors involved in development activities that affect health.
DISTRICT HEALTH AUTHORITY (DHA)
The DHA will comprise representatives from the Local Authorities, the Community Health Committees (who could include service providers from clinics, CHCs or community hospitals), the Director of District Health Services, and the Heads of the District Health Units.
The main functions of the DHA and its staff will be to promote primary health care and to plan, coordinate, support, supervise and evaluate services, based on national and provincial norms, policies and guidelines. The DHA will receive a budget for primary care and will allocate this to different community level services. It will also receive and control the budgets for, and run, community hospitals in the district.
Community hospitals (also known as District or non-specialist hospitals) will be an important component of district health care. At these hospitals general practitioner services, including basic anaesthesia and surgery, will be provided. Specialist services may be provided under exceptional circumstances. Community hospitals will work very closely with CHCs and will provide in-patient care close to where people live. They will be staffed by a team of full-time workers and will be visited regularly by specialists from the provincial (specialist) hospital with which they are linked.
The DHA will also be responsible for ensuring that there are efficient referral systems within the district and between the district and provincial and national facilities such as hospitals and training institutions.
MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE
This committee will be responsible for the day-to-day management of the district health services, will be led by the Director of District Health Services, and will comprise the Director and the Heads of the District Health Units.
DISTRICT HEALTH ADVISORY BODY
To ensure community participation and involvement, the DHA will be advised by the District Health Advisory Body, made up of representatives of Community Health Committees, community-based organisations, trade unions, professional bodies and other health worker organisations.
The DHA will ensure that all health services in the district are rendered within the norms, policies and guidelines agreed to at provincial and national levels, in order to promote equity.
PLANNING AND HUMAN RESOURCES
The current provincial health administrations, self-governing territories, former TBVC states and the regional offices of the Department of National Health and Population Development (DNHPD) will be incorporated into the new provincial authorities. Within the single National Health System each province will support, monitor and evaluate district level services and will provide certain provincial level services.
This body will be similar in concept and function to the District and Community Development Committees and will comprise those members of the Development Committee provincial legislature (Members of the Executive Committee - MECs) responsible for all sectors impacting on health. Its task will be to identify development needs in the province and to mobilise and allocate resources to the best advantage of the people of that province, particularly the poorest.
The PHA will be responsible for the health of all the people of that province and its main task will be to support and supervise the DHAs. Vital components of this support will be specialist hospitals and services, the organisation of training and the coordination, evaluation and planning of primary care services.
Specialists working at provincial institutions will visit district health facilities regularly to provide support and specialist teaching, to learn from the people at district and community level, and to facilitate efficient referral between primary, secondary and tertiary care facilities.
The PHA will be accountable to the elected provincial government and will be chaired by the MEC for Health. Members will include the Provincial Director for Health Services, Heads of the Provincial Health Departments, and representatives from the DHAs. It will, within national guidelines, control the budget allocated for provincial health services. It will also coordinate and monitor the budgets allocated to the DHAs.
This is responsible for the day-to-day management of the provincial health services, and is led by the Provincial Director of Health Services, and comprises the Director and the Heads of the Provincial Departments.
All specialist hospitals will be coordinated by the PHA. Day to day management of these institutions will be delegated to the staff appointed to run them so that they will have a high degree of decentralised administration but they will remain part of the public sector. Planning, budgeting and general policies will be initiated within institutions and then discussed and coordinated by the PHA.
Whereas these hospitals should not provide care that could be provided at a lower level, they should, like clinics and other components of the health services, be accessible and affordable to all who need their level of care. They form an integral part both of the country's health care system, and of the overall social and economic development of the community.
Apart from their role in providing individual patient care, specialist hospitals can support primary care workers through efficient referral and consultation systems. They can also support and conduct relevant research and they have a role to play in both basic and continuing education and training of all types of health workers.
Academic hospitals as currently defined must form an integral part of the referral networks of the province and the country. To ensure the rational and optimal utilisation of these national resources, certain services will only be provided at designated facilities. These hospitals will therefore be coordinated by, and be accountable to. the National Health Authority.
The Provincial Health Authority will receive input from a Provincial Health Advisory Body, similar in concept and composition to that at district level, and will include representatives of stake-holders in the private health sector and of civil society.
The PHA will promote community participation and involvement through liaison with community organisations, trade unions, NGOs involved in health, private providers and their organisations, and other stake-holders in the province with a view to rendering a high quality service in terms of the needs of the province. It will also ensure that multisectoral collaboration takes place for the proper development of health programmes and healthy lifestyles
The single, comprehensive, equitable and integrated National Health System will be planned and coordinated at the central government level.
As with the other levels of the system, all sectors affecting health should be represented on this committee, which will therefore comprise the relevant government Ministers. It will be responsible for intersectoral liaison with other ministries.
This will be chaired by the Minister of Health, and will include the Secretary for Health, Heads of the National Divisions, and representatives from the PHAs, and DHAs. The National Health Authority will have overall responsibility for the development and provision of all health care in South Africa. It will be responsible for policy formulation and strategic planning, as well as coordination of planning and the functioning of the overall health system in the country. It will also develop guidelines, norms and standards to apply throughout the health system, and to translate policy into relevant integrated programmes in health development. The central level will elaborate policy statements and health legislation, and will coordinate international and donor support.
The NHA will allocate and distribute the health budget, and coordinate both public and private health care. Funding will be allocated in a manner which encourages local approaches and responsibility for health service delivery.
This advises the NHA, and has representation from the statutory bodies, the national associations of health professionals, NGOs involved in health, trade unions and national community structures.
The NHA will promote community involvement through liaison with the structures of civil society, including trade unions, NGOs involved in health, private providers and their organisations, and other stake-holders, with a view to rendering high quality health services in terms of the people's needs and to eliminating disparities between the regions. Responsibility for the development of the multisectoral collaboration necessary for the implementation of health programmes and healthy lifestyles, as well as for the coordination of training systems for health personnel, rests with the NHA.
HEALTH CARE
The private health sector is a large industry, comprising a number of different institutions, organisations and personnel. These include inter alia the pharmaceutical industry, medical technology industry, private hospitals and facilities, medical aids, and a range of private practitioners including traditional and complementary health healers. The high cost spiral within the health care industry necessitates a restructuring and a change in the ethos of the private sector, in consultation with all relevant role players.
The current structure of the private sector has created incentives which detract from the ultimate objective of health for all, and instead has created incentives which allow financial interests to take precedence over the patients' interests. It is a system which has been abused by some, and this detracts from the constructive role that the private sector has been playing.
Under the new and dynamic National Health System restructuring of the private sector can enhance its important role in improving the health of the nation. Active cooperation between the private and public sectors will promote a positive climate in which the two sectors can work together, with the common goal of achieving health for all.
The private practitioner is an important, and often underestimated resource at the primary level of care. It is hoped that the majority of private practitioners of all categories will work increasingly in the public sector, deriving their income from health authorities, but maintaining their independence. This group of practitioners will be referred to as "independent practitioners"
Independent practitioners will be encouraged to form multi-disciplinary group practices which will be recognised as an important contribution to comprehensive health care at the primary level. Independent practitioners play an important role in improving access to the health system, especially in areas where services are difficult to provide. Equity in the distribution of independent practitioners will be encouraged through incentives to work in underserved areas. Licensing for practices will be instituted to act as an attraction for underserved areas, and disincentive for overserviced areas. Private practitioners will also be encouraged to work in public clinics, health centres and hospitals on a regular rotational basis. They will have ready access to the CHCs for the follow-through of their patients. Incentives will also be used to encourage health promotional and preventive activities.
The rational and appropriate use of resources is essential. The private sector can play an effective role in helping to identify and implement alternative, more cost-effective therapies. This can be done through the development of therapeutic guidelines, clinical audit, peer and utilisation reviews. All health workers in both public and private sectors will be encouraged to follow agreed NHS protocol for the care of common conditions, including appropriate referral of patients.
The cost spiral within the private sector can be largely attributed to expenditure on drugs and private hospitals. A system of nondiscriminatory pricing of drugs, and generic substitution will be effective in helping to contain costs on drug expenditure. In addition, systems of repayment such as capitation fees or other systems of remuneration will be investigated to replace, were possible, fee-for-service payments in order to reduce the incentive to over-service patients. In the same spirit, action will be taken to ensure that the income of health workers who prescribe medication does not in any way depend on what or how much medication they prescribe.
The state will no longer subsidise the private sector. A better regulatory framework will be applied to the licensing of private sector facilities. Other systems of remuneration will be investigated to replace fee-for-service payments in private health facilities to reduce the incentive to over-service.
Conflicts of interest that promote over- or under-servicing whereby the patient's interest is subordinated to the financial interest of the health worker or institution, will be discouraged. In particular health practitioners will not be permitted to hold shares in private clinics and hospitals.
Traditional healers play an important role in the health care of a large proportion of population, and the need for a coordinating body will be investigated. The role of complementary health practitioners needs to be recognised, and mechanisms to integrate them into the NHS require investigation.
All statutory bodies relevant to health will be reviewed with a perspective directed towards rationalisation. Coordination between the statutory bodies is required to ensure that they interpret and implement national health policies.
The objectives of those Statutory Bodies that govern the registration of health personnel shall be to:
NGOs have historically provided local health services under a variety of conditions in South Africa. In most cases NGO services have filled a void created by neglect of health care needs for underserved populations. In many instances NGOs have paved the way for development of sustainable health care services at the community level. In other instances NGOs have the capacity to create innovative services which do not fit into conventional health service provision.
The Government will create, within the national policy, a framework that takes into account specific objectives of NGOs, rationalisation of services, supervision of standards of care and promotion of efficiency and outcome measures. The payment for the provision of specific services will depend on the submission of budgets and performance appraisal. Their services need to be integrated into, and coordinated with the rest of the health services in order to avoid fragmentation, and where they meet the needs of communities they must be encouraged and supported.
The government has the responsibility to define areas for which external support is needed. However, it is not only financial resources that international agencies can bring to South Africa's health care reconstruction efforts. International agencies can provide technical assistance and appropriate technology for each level of the country's public and private health sector. A further contribution, is the sharing of knowledge and experience about successful PHC in other countries.
It is imperative that the government swiftly organises a special body to coordinate the significant foreign assistance that will be offered to South Africa as it prepares to reconstruct its health system.
The primary concern of management development in the post-apartheid era is to establish, strengthen and sustain the health infrastructure and management systems which will help to:
The future health managers at all levels will deal with issues of planning, coordination and integration, financial management, and human resource management.
Free health care will be provided in the public sector for children under six, pregnant and nursing mothers, the elderly, the disabled, and certain categories of the chronically ill. Preventive and promotive activities, school health services, antenatal and delivery services, contraceptive services, nutrition support, and curative care for public health problems will also be free, in the public sector.
Because of the burden associated with paying for health services at the time of illness, in the long term we are committed to the provision of free health care at the point of service for all citizens of South Africa.
Individuals covered by some form of health insurance will not be eligible to receive free health care. User fees for insured patients using public sector facilities will be increased to ensure full cost recovery. For certain categories of treatment offered only at public hospitals, the fees charged will be negotiated with the insurers.
In addition, user fees may be charged to discourage inappropriate use of the health services. For example, in order to promote better use of the referral system, patients (both insured and uninsured) may be charged higher fees at secondary and tertiary hospitals if they have not been referred from primary care services. Fees for patients following the referral pathway will take into consideration those fees already paid at the lower level.
Facilities will be allowed to retain a proportion of the revenue generated from user fees to be used for improving the quality of health service provision. Mechanisms will be implemented to ensure that uninsured patients are not refused access because of undue emphasis on paying patients. The remainder of the fee revenue will be submitted to the Ministry of Health (and not the Treasury) for redistribution to promote equity in health service provision.
The basis of funding the public health sector will continue to be general tax revenue. Despite the competing claims for limited government resources, particularly for provision of other social services such as education, housing and welfare, it is strongly recommended that health services should receive a higher proportion of general tax revenue. In the past few years, government expenditure on health has fluctuated between 2.8 and 3.4% of GDP (11-12% of total government spending) with a recent trend to decreasing the latter proportion. It is proposed that public spending on health should increase to 4% of GDP (at least 13% of government expenditure). This will provide much needed additional resources for the development of health service infrastructure, and ongoing provision (with an emphasis on the primary care level), in areas that are currently underserved (especially rural and peri-urban areas).
Additional budget allocations to the health sector need not place an additional burden on the state coffers. Additional state revenue can be derived immediately from an increase in the excise on tobacco, which will have an added benefit of reducing consumption. Increased duties on alcohol may also provide revenue, but further studies are required to assess this more fully, especially the health impact of this measure.
Public expenditure on primary care facilities and personnel in rural and impoverished urban areas will be prioritised. Deficient primary care currently compels people to use hospitals for basic care, and deficient secondary hospitals results in the unnecessary use of tertiary hospitals. There will therefore need to be an injection of additional resources to develop primary level infrastructure and services, as well as secondary level hospitals which are vital to the PHC system.
In the short-term, there is limited scope for the redistribution of financial resources between levels of care. A framework will be established for the redistribution of resources on a relative basis by ensuring the highest growth in real expenditure for those services which have been underfunded.
To ensure that such an approach maintains the existing infrastructure, it must be accompanied by the active pursuit of improved efficiency. This includes the strengthening of referral mechanisms, improving health facility management and operational efficiency, and possibly closing or rationalising those facilities which are under-utilised or where there is service duplication.
The current geographical inequities in health care resources must immediately be assessed in terms of the new provincial boundaries, and systematically redressed. This process must be planned so as to ensure that the existing health service infrastructure is not adversely affected. The National Health Authority will coordinate the reallocation of resources, taking into account revenue generation potential for health service provision within each province. The National Health Authority will use the resources at its disposal to subsidise those provinces which are under-funded relative to their needs. The indicators of such needs will include provincial population size, disease patterns, age and gender composition of the population, etc.
The National Health Authority will determine the global health budget for each province (adjusting for revenue generating potential from within provinces). The NHA will also define health sector priorities and provide technical planning guidelines to the Provincial and District Health Authorities. The District Health Authority should be responsible for the actual operational planning (determining financial allocations to individual services and facilities), within the parameters of national priorities and guidelines. The Provincial Health Authorities should be largely responsible for reconciling the district operational plans with available resources, and for planning those services not falling under specific District Health Authorities (e.g. tertiary hospitals).
It is recommended that a Commission of Inquiry be appointed by the Government of National Unity as a matter of urgency, to examine the current crisis in the medical aid sector and to consider alternatives such as a compulsory National Health Insurance (NHI) system. The commission will consult all interested parties, including employer, labour, professional, medical aid, and health insurance organisations. The Commission will investigate the appropriateness and economic feasibility of a National Health Insurance system within the South African context and undertake detailed planning for implementation of an NHI if there is sufficient consensus on this option.
A number of alternative structures for such an NHI should be considered by the commission, namely a single state or para-statal NHI, a single privately administered NHI, or an NHI with the current medical aids acting as the financial intermediaries with pooling of contribution revenue for risk adjustment.
The commission will be asked to investigate the feasibility of an NHI based on the following principles:
Mechanisms must be developed to ensure that the private sector does not Protecting the public sector undermine the public sector services. Two concerns are the loss of highly trained personnel to the private sector after substantial public investment in their training, and the loss of tax revenue in the form of concessions for contributions to medical aids. The former issue could be addressed through a period of compulsory public service for professional graduates. A policy to counter the loss of tax revenue is complex and the tax concession needs to be reviewed. This should be done by the proposed Commission of Inquiry, working in conjunction with the Department of Finance. While it is likely that some tax concession should remain, it could be adjusted, restructured, and used to promote equitable, comprehensive care.
The administration and management of financial resources for health will reflect the thrust of health policies, that is, the recognition of individuals, families, communities and the health system as partners in the provision, financing and management of health care services.
Health financing mechanisms and sources noted above defined the macroeconomic context. A complementary microeconomic analysis, including cost-effective and cost-benefit analyses, will ensure the optimal allocation of funds and, eventually, the attainment of expected outputs.
Within this context, programme budgeting will be effectively promoted to ensure that national, provincial and district allocations not only comply with established planning figures but also allow for adequate monitoring and evaluation of health programmes and interventions at all levels of the health system.
Multisectoral coordination will ensure the provision of the infrastructure required for the efficient functioning of the health delivery system, particularly at provincial and district levels.
The basic financial management functions of the health system will be put in place to control costs of health care interventions, to ensure regular supply and distribution of goods and services, and to guarantee the collection and utilisation of relevant information for decision-making on health care financing. More specifically, the following strategic options will be implemented.
Although South Africa has large numbers of highly skilled health workers, much of their training has been inappropriate and they are poorly distributed in relation to health and health care needs. The transformation of the health system to one based on the PHC approach will require reorientation of existing personnel, fuller use of their present skills, and in-service training and acquisition of new skills to enable them to play a more effective role in promoting, maintaining and restoring health. There will also need to be changes in basic training, and the development of new categories of health personnel.
The primary concern of this policy is to support the aims of the National Health System. The policy is designed to respond to the needs of underserved communities and to strengthen primary health care. It considers health personnel to be agents for transforming health and its socio-political environment and it sees health personnel education as a shared responsibility of community, service, and training institutions. It needs to be multidisciplinary, gender-sensitive and community-based in character. Career path flexibility, review, and the redress of historical maldistribution are other prominent features.
A number of actions are required, which will include the following:
The government will continue to subsidise the training of health workers at tertiary education institutions. Personnel education will be the shared responsibility of community, service and training institutions and will be coordinated nationally. The standards of total health care will be raised through a comprehensive system of continuing education, including reviews of the skills and competencies of health personnel.
A broad range of people need to be involved in the selection of students for health education institutions including community members, students and health workers from different service levels. All health education institutions must ensure that the composition of their student bodies reflect society in terms of gender, race and geographic distribution. This will require the application of affirmative action principles in the short to medium term in order to redress present imbalances. Effective integrated academic development programmes will be established to strengthen the capacity of all students entering health institutions.
All health education programmes will be facilitated by the introduction of stepwise certification of all categories of health personnel to match their competence to deliver specific levels of care. Training curricula should enable maximum flexibility for movement across and within different parts of the health system. Each occupational category will have clearly laid out career paths for advancement or transition to management, educational or research roles.
Fast-track training programmes will be introduced to train personnel in priority areas including management, environmental health and diagnosis and clinical care at the primary level. Community Health Workers may also be trained in areas where there is local community and health service support for them.
Tertiary hospitals have very important and specific roles to play in specialist education, in clinical research and in supporting primary and secondary care services, but most training of health personnel will be at the district and community levels.
Rotation through primary and secondary level facilities in under-served areas will be part of postgraduate as well as part of pre-registration training.
Guidelines will be developed for the size and composition of the teams needed at different levels but the emphasis will be on the quality of services rather than on rigid staffing norms. Where necessary the numbers and categories of staff working at primary and secondary care levels will be increased. Proper recognition will be given to the major role of nurses in the health system.
The redistribution of health personnel to under-served areas will be addressed by the provision of selected incentives for personnel such as career opportunities, financial, fringe and study benefits, infrastructural support and amenities. Compulsory service in underserved areas will also be introduced for all qualifying health personnel.
In order to deal with the problems created by the present fragmentation and inconsistencies in salary levels between different health authorities, it is recommended that conditions of service for all health workers in the public sector, including salary scales, be negotiated nationally. A Commission of Inquiry into the conditions of service and employment of all health workers in the public sector will be established as a matter of urgency. It should consult widely with all interested parties including all the public sector unions and employers, and must make recommendations within six months.
Community Health Workers can play a unique role in promoting health and in expanding and improving health services provided they have effective support structures and referral systems and they receive ongoing training. They can also be catalysts for community development, mobilising people around health issues. Local programmes will be encouraged provided they are integrated into the local health services, but no national programme will be launched at this stage.
Effective labour relations will be promoted through accepted recognition and negotiation agreements with health worker organisations. Better conditions of service and clear grievance procedures will help to avoid strikes or other industrial action which could compromise patient care.
A comprehensive health information system that begins at the local level and feeds into provincial and national levels is essential. It will consist of the collection, organisation, reporting, storage and use of data for planning and managing promotional activities and health care services. International standards or definitions will be used wherever practicable to ensure that the country can be integrated into, and benefit from, international data reporting systems. The system will be sufficiently flexible to incorporate data arising from research programmes. It must also be able to incorporate data gathered from other sectors.
The information gathered will fall into four broad categories:
The Health Information System will cover both public and private health care sectors. Information requirements must be established at each level of the health services related to their needs and according to national guidelines.
Specific indicators will be included to monitor the apartheid-generated disparities in health status and access to health care, and in order to do this data will be disaggregated by gender, and in the short term, by "race" as previously defined by the apartheid state.
Information collected by the system will be used for strategic planning, for policy formulation, for monitoring health care delivery, for evaluating specific health care programmes, and for assessing and reviewing progress on district, provincial and national plans. Where necessary, the confidentiality of information collected will be assured, and at all times the accuracy of the data collected will be monitored.
Ongoing development of the Health Information System, and national analyses and comparisons, will be one of the responsibilities of the National Health Authority. Health objectives, health indicators, data collection forms, existing information systems and information technology will all be reviewed, adapted or developed. Those of the 27 health indicators developed by the WHO Regional Office for Africa that are relevant to South Africa will be included. Training in the collection of health information data will be included in the curricula of all health workers.
Legislation will be amended or developed to facilitate the introduction of the national health information system and the enforcement of its ethical aspects. A national health information bulletin will be published to document changes in health and health care, to help provide feedback to those who collect data and to encourage rational decision making.
As has been indicated, the lack of comprehensive or even comparable data, and the generally poor quality of the data that are available, makes rational planning difficult. Priorities and targets have been set within these limitations and will be adjusted as better data become available.
The percentages given are national averages which may mask very marked differences between different provinces, districts or communities. Each district and province must therefore aim to achieve a significant improvement in each of the target areas every year.
The order of priorities may vary from one part of the country to another. Priorities identified in a number of areas such as the provision of clean water, sanitation, housing, employment, education, electricity and telephones have not been included here. They often have an even greater impact on health than the health services alone. However, as they are elaborated in the Reconstruction and Development Programme, there are not repeated here.
The speed with which specific goals can be met and targets achieved often depends on the financial implications, and the time taken to adjust budgets and/or to enact new legislation. Both the financial and legal processes may, therefore, affect the order and speed with which the priorities are implemented.
All planning, including priority setting, must be an interactive and dynamic process. Targets will therefore be reviewed regularly both in the light of new information as it becomes available and in the light of comments, criticisms and new ideas.
The health policy priorities included in this chapter are the following:
Principal Health Priorities
Maternal and Child Health Nutrition Control of Communicable Diseases Violence Special Programmes for Vulnerable Groups
Other Health Priorities
Health Promotion Drug Policy Emergency Care Substance Abuse Oral Health Environmental Health
Financing Facilities Human Resources Management Educational and Research Institutions
- Targets/timing
- Recommendation by Minister of Health by June 1994
- Legislation enacted by 1995
- 80% of children under 2 years have weight recorded regularly
- Progressive reduction in proportion of children with low weight for age
- 50% deliveries supervised and carried out under hygienic conditions by end 1995
- 80% coverage by end 1999
- Over 60% of pregnant women attending clinics at least once by end 1995
- Free services by end 1997
- Measles coverage to 80% by end 1995
- Measles coverage to 90% by end 1997
- Road to health cards held by 80% children by end 1995
- Eradication of polio and neonatal tetanus by end 1999
- At least 70% of target population breast feeding at 6 months by end 1995
- Increased awareness in all sections of population
- Ratify within 6 months of Parliament sitting
- Legislation reviewed and adjustments enacted by end 1996
- Targets/timing
- Extension of the list of basic foodstuffs exempt from VAT
- Consider and implement price controls and subsidies on basic foodstuffs
- Provide nutrition supplementation to people receiving grants, to vulnerable groups, and to those in relief areas
- Reduce prevalence of severe malnutrition by 40% by end 1997
- Increase pensions to those for whom this is their sole source of income
- Targets/timing
- Establish strategies to improve diagnosis, treatment management, compliance and effective follow up
- Start an immunisation campaign by end 1995 to prevent the spread of Hepatitis B
- Determine current incidence
- Reduce current incidence
- Improved management of acute respiratory infections
- All schools to be running comprehensive education programmes on a regular basis by January 1996
- Develop and implement an effective HIV/AIDS strategy by end 1995
- Develop of STD/HIV counselling and support services at all CHCs by end 1999
- Report the number of cases of HIV-AIDS
- Targets/timing
- Develop and coordinate mental health services
- Legislation for the protection of women and children by the end of 1995
- Counselling services accessible at CHCs, including referral path to other levels, by end 1995
- Targets/timing
- Improve universal access to reproductive health services
- Development of occupational health services
- Monitoring and enforcement of existing legislation on occupational health and safety
Rural health
- Improve health services in rural areas
- Provide outreach services to all communities
- Improve health of livestock and adequate standards for food handlers
- Improve the quality of mental health care through community-based care and also improve institutional care
- Improve the detection and control of risk factors and of chronic illness at the primary level, including appropriate referrals, by end 1995
- Improve community-based rehabilitation services coordinated by the CHCs
- Improve in community-based services and institutional care for the elderly
- Targets/timing
- Ensure the establishment of health promotional activities within programmes at all levels of the system by end 1995
- Establishment of an essential drug list by end 1994
- Provision of essential drugs in 80% of CHC facilities by end 1995
- Extension of generic substitution from the public sector to the private sector by end 1996
- Training of appropriate personnel at CHC in first aid by end of 1994
- All health districts to have identified at least one 24-hour facility to provide emergency care by end 1995, including appropriate communications and response services
- Educational programmes in schools, media and health facilities established by 1994/95
- Supporting and developing prevention programmes for drug and alcohol abuse
- Apply strict regulations on the advertising of tobacco and alcohol b end 1995
- Increase excise duties on tobacco by end 1994
- Review the effect of increasing prices of alcohol in reducing consumption
- Extend regulations creating smoke-free zones to include public places, working environments, and government buildings
- Introduction of measures to fluoridate the mouth, including fluoridation of existing and future developments of water supplies, and provision of fluoride supplementation, by end 1995
- Education programmes to improve diagnosis of early oral lesions for all health workers by end 1999
- Endorse and Implement the Rio Declaration on Environment and Development by July 1994
- Carry out health impact studies on the effects of major economic developments
- Monitor respiratory diseases related to air pollution
- Targets/timing
- Development of national formulae for the allocation of the health budget between and within provinces by end 1995
- District and provincial funds to be allocated to address inequalities by April 1996
- Establish commission by June 1994, and to report within six months
- No user fees charged for these services and target groups in the public sector by end 1994
- Recommendations made by end 1994
- Targets/timing
- At least 75% of the population lives within reach of a primary care service by end 1995, especially in the rural areas
- Number of services needed identified by end 1994
- National standards and norms defined
- Facilities built to redress backlog taking into account future needs by 1999.
- Ensure existing facilities are capable of delivering quality health care
- Initiate discussions on rationalisation of tertiary care institutions
- Appropriate regulations by end 1995
- Targets/timing
- Elaboration of a long term programme for personnel to cover the needs of the NHS by end 1995
- Training of appropriate primary care providers
- Provide at least one diagnostician, and environmental health personnel to every CHC
- Define and implement incentives to reallocate personnel to the underserved areas
- 25% of district health personnel trained by end 1995, and 50% by end 1997
- Analysis of competency and skill levels for new cadres by end 1995
- Implement integration by end 1999
- Targets/timing
- Appoint a Commission of Inquiry by end June 1994, and to report within 6 months
- Establish the structure and line management functions of the NHS for decentralised decision making to the lowest effective level by end 1994
- Definition of essential information required at each level, including an epidemiological surveillance system by end 1994
- Training of personnel at all levels and facilities by end 1995
- Commencement of collection of information at all levels by end 1995
- Utilisation of existing data to define and monitor health priorities by end 1994
- Targets/timing
- Reorientation of educational institutions in terms of community-based orientation and accessibility
- Review the need for new educational and research institutions according to the needs of the country by end 1996
- Promote and implement affirmative action
- Review all existing health research, and resources for health research by end 1994
- Evaluate and coordinate health related research
- Establish health research priorities by end 1995
- Targets/timing
- Definition of the powers and functions of the National, Provincial, and District Health Authorities by end May 1994
- Review the Health Act, Health Policy Act, and legislation relevant to health personnel with the aim to make the necessary changes to respond to the National Health Plan by end June 1994
- Enact new legislation by end August 1994
- Legislation for priority areas
- Prioritise the legislation to be reviewed in the short to medium term by July 1994
- Other legislation during the period of the Government of National Unity
The ANC gratefully acknowledges the support of:
Dr. G L Monekosso and the Regional Office for Africa of the World Health Organization; Ms Scholastica Kimaryo and the United Nations Childrens Fund; and the following WHO and UNICEF consultants, led by Dr David Tembo
Drs. J Alwar, L Arevshatian, S Lazzari, K Ojo, P Rojas, R Smith.
The WHO office in Lesotho gave invaluable assistance in the final production of this document.
Many comments were received in the broad process of consultation entered into during the development of this plan. The major contributions and comments on successive drafts came from ANC structures and commissions, and from allied organisations of the Mass Democratic Movement. Many concerned individuals also sent valuable comments, and their contributions (whilst not individually listed) are gratefully acknowledged. In addition, substantial written submissions were received from a wide range of organisations, and we are pleased to acknowledge the following, listed in alphabetical order: